Hot Wings Bracket, Round 1: All-Star vs. Ching’s Wings

January 19, 2012 6:23 pm 2 comments

The second match-up of the first round of the Hot Wings Bracket is sweet and spicy duel between the honey hot wings at All-Star and Ching's Wings.

Here’s how the first round works: In the first round, I’m going to try half orders of  wet wings (meaning, with sauce) from each restaurant. If I have honey hot wings at one wing joint, that's what I'll have at its opponent. I’ll lay out my thoughts on each offering, and you guys will have 24 hours to vote in the poll at the bottom of the post. I’ll cast my vote, too, and the winner will move on to the next round. You can only vote once in each match up.

Let's meet the contenders:

All-Star Hot Wings

286 North Cleveland Street
Memphis, TN 38104-7146
(901) 272-8728
 
Honey hot five wing combo, comes with five whole wings, fries and a drink for $6.99
 
Honey Hot Wings, All-Star
When I opened my to-go box from All-Star (all of the orders, even if you're dining in are served in to-go boxes) I was pleasantly surprised that whoever packed it had created a wax paper divider between my five whole wings and the crinkle fries.
 
The wings were dripping with sauce that, like some middle school girls, was sweet at first, but delivered some serious mouth-punching spice. The wings walked a fine line between crispy and soft, and an order of five was plenty of food. The fries weren't anything special, just standard once-frozen crinkle fries.
 
All-Star was nearly empty when I ate there, but there was a steady stream of people coming in to pick up to-go orders. The staff was friendly, and the TV was tuned to Dr. Drew.
 
Napkin Rating (aka, number of napkins used in the eating of the wings): roughly 10. They were seriously spicy wings, and the napkins were way too thin for the task.
 
Napkins at All-Star Wings
 
And the contender:
 
Ching's Wings
 
1264 Getwell Road
Memphis, TN 38111-7345

(901) 743-5545

Ching's Hot Wings on Urbanspoon

10 honey hot "party wings" (half wings), fries and "blue drink", about $9.

Honey hot wings from Ching's Wings, Memphis, Tenn.

Ching's honey hot wings were also served in a to-go container, but I ate every single one at the restaurant. The skins were crisp, the meat was juicy, and the sauce was firey enough to satisfy my need for heat, but had enough honey to be just the right ammount of sweet.

The wings were fairly coated in sauce, but it stuck to the chicken pretty well, leaving just enough in the to-go box to sop up with the included roll. The fries were standard crinkle cut fries, but Ching's dresses them up with some of the same lemon pepper seasoning they use on their dry-rub wings.

When I went around dinner time (on a week night), there were a lot of people eating at the restaurant, inculding what had to be the entirety of the U of M softball team. Ching's is also the only place I know of where you can watch seven different basketball games simultaneously in a room the size of my kitchen while photos of smiling Tiger athletes smile from frames that have been nailed to every available surface.

Napkin rating: again, about 10, but Ching's goes the extra mile and puts both hand sanitizer and Clorox wipes on every table.

Napkins, Ching's Wings, Memphis, Tenn.

So, who's it going to be? You've got until 5 p.m. tomorrow to cast your vote. The winner will go up against Bosses in the second round.

2 Comments

  • Ate at All-Star Wings for lunch with 3 friends. The service was friendly, and the wings and fries were served hot out of the fryer. Two plusses so far!
    Our table sampled XHot, Suicide and Honey Hot. The wings were good sized and slathered in sauce. For my taste, the XHot and Honey Hot were not really all that hot (with spice that is). Finally got a little burn going with the Suicide sauce.
    The big question is would I go back? The wings were good, but not so good that I can't wait to go back for more. I like my wings a little less messy. Next time I would ask for dry wings with sauce on the side.
    Of the three wing places (Central BBQ, Bosses, All-Star) I've tried, I prefer the wings at Bosses. I hope to try Ching's soon for comparison.

  • The combo at Chings comes out to $9.01. That little tribute to Memphis (I refuse to believe this is a coincidence) is reason enough to vote for them!

Leave a Reply


Other News